Neural Networks Explained?

On 2026-11-16 7:22 p.m., in response to some suggestions from Bob Worcester, I wrote:

I think the 3b1b series (starting with https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aircAruvnKk) is well worth digging into. The second link you sent (at https://youtu.be/olDwTWN9vs4?si=NYKdlvasO6nOhA0N ) is an interesting example of something, but I think is wrong to identify the iterations of Newton’s method as training runs of a learning system. And this last one (at  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmmW0F0biz0&t=10s )is I think “less complicated” only because it explains so much less (and overlooks the importance, explained in the second one, of NON-linear behaviour of a neuron).

On 2026-11-16 11:41 a.m., Robert Worcester wrote:

This is a less complicated explanation of neural networks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmmW0F0biz0&t=10s

On 2026-11-12 8:34 a.m., Robert Worcester wrote:

The best simple explanation I have run across so far.

https://youtu.be/olDwTWN9vs4?si=NYKdlvasO6nOhA0N

The math is (to me) scary BUT the organic structure that this machinery seek to emulate is MUCH more complicated than the math.  Where does physics become biology (or vise versa)?

On Wed, 11 Nov 2026 at 07:58, Robert Worcester wrote:

Hi – In response to our discussions yesterday I was motivated to try to better “understand” how neural networks (wet or dry) actually work.

I found this helpful though I confess I don’t really understand the math of linear algebra BUT it looks potentially “understandable.”

I am wondering if a mathematician can facilitate the transmission of the neural weightings necessary for such understanding?

A Simple Model Neuron is something that accepts as input (from a set of sources which we’ll call its “dendritic contacts” or “upstream layer”) a discrete set of signal strengths (each of which can be represented by a real number), and for each such collection of inputs sends to a destination (which we’ll call its “downstream channel” or “axon”) an output signal (of the same kind as the inputs). But in order to be useful for learning, it must ALSO accept inputs that it interprets as requests to increase or decrease its output value, to which it responds with some combination of adjusting its own behaviour and/or passing on requests for changes of its other inputs. Such requests coming, either directly or indirectly, from the output channel are referred to as “back propagation”. This can be done in various ways, and the details may be hard to follow, so it is often left out of discussions of how to model a single neuron.

For example, the model of a single neuron from 1:05 to 3:15 in the video by Aviraj Ingle deals well enough with the forward process but omits any reference to the adjustment capability which is required for “back propagation” in neural networks. [This is followed by a section in which oddly combines discussion of the need for nonlinearity in order for network “layers” to be useful with how cutoffs enhance the capabilities of a single layer, and then an example in which back propagation is actually used without ever having been properly explained and in which iteration of steps in producing the response to a single data set is confounded with the process of training with different sample data sets.]

A common form for the forward propagation through a single neuron just takes a weighted sum of the inputs giving result $#r=\Sigma w_{i} x_{i}#$ and then gives (or perhaps just goes towards) $#0#$ for results $#r#$ that are smaller than some lower cutoff $#m#$, and $#1#$ for all that are larger than some upper cutoff $#M#$, and scales intermediate results between $#m#$ and $#M#$ into outputs between $#0#$ and $#1#$. [We can do this in many ways – eg with strict cutoffs and linear scaling to get $#y=(\frac{1}{2}+\frac{|r-m|-|r-M|}{2(M-m)})#$, or more smoothly with a “sigmoid” $#y=\sigma(z)=(\frac{1}{1+e^{-z}})#$ with $#z=(r-\frac{m+M}{2})(\frac{4}{M-m})#$]

Even without back-propagation, if we choose the weights and cutoffs directly then such a neuron does provide a model for making or predicting some simple kinds of decision. For example if someone is in a situation where they have access to a down jacket but no waterproof layer and we want to predict the probability of whether or not they will go out on the basis of the predicted probabilities of cold and wet weather, then we might assign a high negative weight to the probability of precipitation and a low negative weight to the probability of having a temperature below 10 Celsius. But if we expect that they have some desire to actually go out then we might have a lower cutoff corresponding to how strong we expect that desire to be and the probability that they actually decide to go out might then be equal to the output from such a neuron with inputs equal to the applicable probabilities of rain and cold. Or in biology, such a fixed-weight neuron might enable a simple organism to decide whether or not to move on the basis of its sensitivities to the concentrations of various offensive chemicals in its environment with a cutoff based on its need not to waste energy in unnecessary motion. But in such cases the neuron just has fixed behaviour – either evolved over many generations or put in by a human, and there is no immediate learning involved.

It may seem that the use of linear functions is unduly restrictive, but with the inclusion of cutoffs a bunch of such neurons acting in parallel can approximately model any smooth function.

For example, the function $#f(x)=1-x^2#$ for $#-1<x<1#$ can be approximated to within $#\pm0.1#$ by the piecewise linear function $#f(x)=2(x+1) for -1<x<-3/4 ; 1+2x/3 for -3/4<x<0; 1-2x/3 for 0<x<3/4; and -2(x-1) for 3/4<x<1#$ which is just the sum of the outputs of four single input neurons. But here the neurons have been given their weights by me and there was no learning involved.

Now let’s re-introduce the learning process.

Rather than put in the actual weights and cutoffs we can start by putting in random values and let the neurons themselves figure out what to do. But for this we need them to be able to detect where they went wrong and have some way they can arrange to do better.

Here’s an example with two inputs. If we call the input values $#x_1#$ and $#x_2#$ and the output is initially given by $#y=w_1x_1+w_2x_2#$, then a request to increase the output can be met by adjusting the “weights” $#w_1#$ and $#w_2#$ in various ways but for fixed input values the fastest increase per unit “distance” in the $#(w_1,w_2)#$ space is when the change $#(\Delta w_1,\Delta w_2)#$ is parallel to the input vector $#(x_1,x_2)#$. [And also, if we are able to change the inputs, then for any given values of $#w_1#$ and $#w_2#$ the output can be increased by requesting an increment of the input values for which the most efficient choice is when $#(\Delta x_1,\Delta x_2)#$ is parallel to the weights vector $#(w_1,w_2)#$.]

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

End of Math?

Scientific American’s December 2026 cover declares AI to be bringing “The End of Math As We Know It”. But I beg to differ.

It is not Math itself as I know it that will change, but perhaps rather the culture of priority-worship that surrounds it and which I actually quite despise – partly because it so often gets the story wrong, but also largely due to the fact that I have never had any expectation of being able to answer a question that all others could not. So for me the only motivation has been to increase my own understanding of what I can be sure of, and to simplify whatever I take as proof of that to a form that I can remember (and which might give me some value to others who share that goal).

Source: AI has finally come for math—mathematicians might never recover | Scientific American

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Dodgy Pronouns and Phantom Identities – Clive Hamilton

I have my own reservations about some aspects of the whole “gender identity” business. But the objections of Clive Hamilton are ill-founded. He asserts that on registering for a festival/conference:

I have been asked to nominate my gender. In fact, the form asks me to nominate my “Gender Identity” and gives four options.

The options presuppose that sex, biological sex, is either irrelevant or subsumed within the category of “gender identity.” The word “identifying” quietly introduces the premise that sex is a matter of self-ascription rather than biological fact.

But there is no indication that the organizers care about or are asking him to declare his sex or even his actual gender. The fact that they do not care about these things does NOT imply that they consider them to be globally “either irrelevant or subsumed within the category of ‘gender identity’ “. The event in question is not an orgy but just an occasion where the actual sex of the participants is indeed irrelevant but where, largely because of some peculiarities of language, the gender identity is needed in order to reduce the chances of giving unnecessary offense when referring indirectly to participants.

Source: Dodgy Pronouns and Phantom Identities – Clive Hamilton

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

What is Beauty … for?

A few weeks ago my friend Bob Worcester introduced our weekly coffee klatch to the work of Mary Oliver by way of identifying the questions “What is beauty?” (from The Leaf and the Cloud: O what is beauty, that I should be up at four a.m. trying to arrange this thick song? What is beauty that I should bow down in the fields of the world, as though someone, somewhere made it?) and “What is beauty for?” (from The Swan: And did you feel it, in your heart, how it pertained to everything? And have you too finally figured out what beauty is for? And have you changed your life?)

Much of Oliver’s work is devoted to the redemptive power of beauty, and in an address at Wellesley College in 2010 she famously said “The universe could have been created ugly, and would have functioned. And yet there is beauty everywhere in creation. Beauty gives us an ache, to be worthy of that creation.”

Those are indeed beautiful sentiments, so I regret the fact that by comparison what follows may seem ugly. Reader discretion is advised.

What is beauty?

That “beauty is in the eye of the beholder” has the sound of a line that might have been written by Shakespeare for a character such as Polonius or Portia – capable of conveying either great wisdom or vacuous superficiality depending on the needs and intent of the production. In fact, although those exact words were first written in the 19th century (by Irish author Margaret Wolfe Hungerford in her 1878 novel Molly Bawn), Shakespeare did write something very similar in Love’s Labour’s Lost, namely “Beauty is bought by judgment of the eye”.

But the sentiment actually has much deeper roots – having been expressed in other words by sages as ancient as Laozi (“When the world knows beauty as beauty, ugliness arises”) and Zhuangzi (who pointed out that legendary beauties such as Mao Qiang and Xi Shi were adored by men, but if fish saw them they would dive deep, and if birds saw them they would fly away – and then asked “Which of these four knows what is truly beautiful in the world?”), or in the 10th century Chinese idiom 情人眼里出西施, meaning literally “in the eyes of a lover, Xi Shi appears” .

In the Western world, Plato of course had the opposite view, but that was in reaction to relativist sentiments similar to those above that were also current in Greece at his time – especially those of Protagoras (who is credited with the claim that “Man is the measure of all things”).

But acceptance that words (especially but not exclusively those expressing value) can mean different things to different people does not preclude our looking for common elements that appear to be included in everyone’s usage. And when it comes to the word “beauty” in modern English I think there are some interesting subtleties.

In particular, I think the word “beauty” conveys something beyond mere attractiveness; and even in the strictly visual context it seems to convey something deeper than, say, prettiness.

Two possible questions one might ask about what we mean by “beauty” are what, if any, emotional responses cause us to describe something as beautiful; and what, if any, objective features of an experience tend to induce those responses.

With regard to the former, I would suggest that we describe something as beautiful if it arouses positive feelings that we admire in ourselves. Unlike simple appetite, lust, or the urge to move in response to a musical rhythm, the appreciation of something as beautiful is a positive response that we feel marks us as of high quality in terms of the society in which we live.

And with regard to the second question, I would say that the kinds of stimulus that induce this response often involve the detection of some not-quite-obvious pattern or symmetry in the stimulus. But maybe that’s just reflective of the culture I was brought up in and others might see beauty in just making everything gold or in the exaggeration of secondary sexual characteristics.

Perhaps a more sophisticated culture than ours might assign two different words here – as the Greeks did for the distinction between erotic and agapeic love. But in any case, although it may be admirable and healthy to find beauty in everything, to insist that beauty is a feature of the universe rather than of the way we look at it strikes me as misguided – and although it may not have been “created ugly” there is surely a lot of what we might reasonably consider ugly in it.

What is Beauty For?

The question “What is beauty for?” can be interpreted in several ways – depending on who or what is expected to gain as a result of the existence of beauty. Are we thinking of how it serves the entity perceived as beautiful? how the experience of beauty benefits the one perceiving or owning the beautiful object? or how the existence of beauty as a concept is useful to us as individuals or as a species?

The elaborate pattern of a peacock’s tail serves the peacock by way of attracting a mate (and the fact that peahens are attracted by the display may be explained by the fact that the energy expenditure involved in growing and bearing such a tail is only survivable by a bird with genes that would also be of value to a female offspring). But the fact that it appears beautiful to us humans is of little use to the bird (except perhaps eventually as a way of assuring that we continue to preserve the species).

For the human viewing the peacock perhaps the value is in being able to enjoy a pleasurable experience whose enjoyment marks one as being of refined taste.

And for the species as a whole perhaps the attraction to contrasting colours may have helped our ancestors find ripe fruit (with the fact that we also see beauty in a poisonous frog

perhaps then being an accidental consequence that was not important on the savannahs where we originally evolved, though it is curious that the kinds of colours and forms that appear beautiful to fruit eaters and pollinators occur also in decorations that were presumably evolved to be repulsive to predators.)

And the capacity for recognizing and being attracted to more subtle patterns may also be useful for finding ways to survive in a constantly changing environment.

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Cultural Appropriation

What is often decried as “cultural appropriation” is not something I am generally prepared to always avoid or disapprove of. Indeed in a world of interacting nations every culture is build from a mish-mash of others that came from before or afar. One particularly silly example of a complaint is the case of the American girl of European ancestry who wore a dress of a style that was once popular in China, but its tight-fitting style actually was adopted in imitation of the tailoring styles and techniques then current in Europe – as opposed to the looser fits of traditional Chinese culture.

Of course, if the appropriation has an overt or covert demeaning intent or effect then I am prepared to consider that it might be unacceptable. Unacceptable appropriations might include copying a style of special cultural significance and using it in a context which the originating culture would find offensive (but I might also be prepared to give such offense if I thought that it was for some reason necessary). They also include copying a style of no special significance if done in form of a caricature, and in fact use of the word “woke” does have that kind of a feel for me. It seems a bit like the use of “blackface” in the context of a “minstrel show” with exaggerated gestures – as opposed to the (imo perfectly legitimate) use of makeup to honestly portray a character of different skin colour.

Sometimes (as with English tea drinking) an incorporated element becomes truly “appropriated” as a distinctive element of the appropriating culture, but this does nothing to diminish the value of the practice to its earlier adopters. There may be situations where such appropriation does negatively impact the source culture by stealing its market. This is arguably the case for some indigenous art styles, but it is hard to tell for sure whether the imitators reduce or increase the market for originals so the only cases I might accept restriction of are those involving a specific image class (as opposed to a more general style).

This brings us to the case of cultural documentation (which is how I interpret much of the early work of Emily Carr).

Source: Neale’s blog: Emily Carr without “Indian” Art

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Neale’s blog: Pictures vs. Print

As one who is often frustrated with the pace of spoken words I find that this resonates with me. But that is not to say that I don’t find pictures and animations useful for certain kinds of information. In fact, for me, I’d say that the distinction is not so much between pictures vs print as between text and voice for verbal communication.

And as a further comment I would note that while we do have written texts to refer to, the intended medium through which we are expected to experience the ambiguities of Hamlet, Macbeth, and Caesar is via spoken words whose intonation often carries more information than the text (and/or directs us to particular interpretations or suggests ones that are different from the directly literal).

Source: Neale’s blog: Pictures vs. Print

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Was Jesus Mad?

If we are to interpret questions about the mental state of a fictional character as being about the intent of the author, then in this case the answer is surely no – as the authors of the gospels clearly did intend readers to believe in the divinity of their subject.

But when it comes to whatever real person or person those stories are based on, the idea that they were delusional is plausible – even if we admire the delusion to the extent of calling it a “divine madness”. Though on the other hand, it is also possible that a sane person might choose to claim godhead without actually believing in it for the purpose of achieving some political or social goal.

Source: Neale’s blog

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Does Writing Need an Audience?

My friend Neale Adams is a professional writer who now in retirement finds that writing is in his blood and feels compelled to continue to exercise his craft even though it may now be without financial compensation, but in declaring his plan for writing he indicates that it is important for him to have a responsive (or at least appreciative) audience.

The desire for audience is also expressed by another writing friend of mine, Geoffrey Keyte, who I have long hoped would see the value of making his work accessible online rather than just all in privately circulated print format.

But for me, although I would welcome (and regret the lack of) a sense that I was actually communicating with others, the primary purpose of my own writing is to clarify thoughts in my own mind. Some of that writing might actually be of interest (I hope) but much is just reaction to the writing of others and/or is too cryptic for a wider audience. So I do not agree with Neale’s assertion that “As with speech, the audience is others” . In fact many years ago I wrote that “Not having an audience, I don’t really have the option to persuade anyone, so for me it’s more about clarification and reinforcement of my own thoughts and ideas – and protection against the fear that I will forget them.” And even earlier I wrote something similar.

However, I do value communication and feedback, and once had hopes that the trackback and RSS features of early Blogging technology and would allow the development of a robust network for the exchange of written ideas. Perhaps it did for a while, but hopes were dashed when the owners and controllers of the RSS communication infrastructure saw less profit in such a network of independently hosted sites than in their own “walled gardens” – and/or when people like me became too lazy to manage their own email newsletters. The possible good news on that score is that the Substack platform provides tools for writers to email news of their content to subscription lists (and if interested to collect fees from their subscribers) – and of course also to host and manage comments on their work.

Up to now I have only used Substack to read and comment on the work of others but if I were to use it for building an audience for some more substantial efforts then perhaps a post such as this might be a good place to start.

Source: Neale’s blog: A plan for writing

Posted in uncategorized | 2 Comments

Canada Safe For Now

So there will be no move towards a “binding” referendum while Danielle Smith is Premier – which means I guess we are safe until the end of the UCP convention on Nov 29.

Source: CBC News – Latest Canada, World, Entertainment and Business News

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Dangerous?

When I was young, the Deccan Traps were widely considered to be the most likely explanation of the KT extinction. But discovery of the Iridium signature and Chicxulub crater made it clear that there was another possibility whose short sharp impact would seem much more likely to explain the breadth of that extinction event. It is possible that the evolutionary stress of responding to the environmental fluctuations caused by the on-again-off-again earlier Deccan eruptions would leave the global ecosystem less (but also possibly more?) capable of surviving the impact without such permanent change, and also that such stresses due to eruptions after the impact might have made it harder for some species to recover, but the impact surely played a role. Also, the fact that there is apparently less of a dramatic signature in the foraminifera may be due to their apparent sensitivity to less intense but perhaps longer lasting changes. I don’t know, but the fact that the question of relative importance (of Traps vs Chicxulub) is still being discussed and voted on at conferences makes me doubt that proponents of the older theory are really considered “dangerous” to the scientific community as a whole (despite the unfortunate battle of egos that often distorts science – just as it also does for other domains of perceived human excellence)

Source: the most dangerous woman in science – Google Search

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

No need to fear Cancer!

Palantir CTO Shyam Sankar says some AI researchers are taking up smoking because they expect AI to cure cancer … and the rest of them are doing so because they think that AI will kill us all before the cancer gets them.

Source: Kalshi on X: “JUST IN: Palantir CTO says some AI researchers are taking up smoking because they expect AI to cure cancer. https://t.co/3OV8JGBtOP” / X

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

To Increase Labour Force Participation

US congressman Paul Ryan suggests that UBI should not be supported because it “reduces labor force participation“. Well news flash – unearned wealth of any kind also reduces labor force participation. So is Mr Ryan in favour of limiting or taxing away the major part of all inheritances and gifts?

Source: Paul Ryan on X: “Proponents push Universal Basic Income (UBI) as a cure-all, but the data tells a different story. Recent trials show unconditional cash reduces labor force participation and earnings. Americans deserve better and that’s what states can off

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Rocket Science – Physics Notes

Source: Rocket Science – Physics Notes

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

WestJet Will Face Blowback

I suspect that WestJet and its employees will suffer huge negative consequences as a result of their unnecessary disruption of the lives of thousands of Canadians over an issue that they were able to resolve in just 24 hours of real negotiation. Neither I nor (so far as I am aware) anyone I know had our holiday travels disrupted, and yet I still feel a sense of outrage (despite having had, in my time, to make similarly disruptive decisions affecting the lives of others).

Source: WestJet and CUPE reach tentative agreement, ending job action, flight disruptions

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Washington Post is losing my trust

It may be true that higher education is losing the public’s trust, but this article “has to be read to be believed. No, strike that, I’ve read it(*) three times, and I am still struggling to convince myself that it’s real” [(*)Not only that, but also some of the misrepresented paywalled references] What is particularly “bizarre” and “clueless” is the author’s obsession with the question of whether or not sex is binary(#) – and whether or not it would be appropriate for an anthropology conference to include a panel advocating study based on the assumption that it is.

Of course it may be appropriate for anthropologists to look at how the false belief that sex is a binary characteristic affects the development of some cultures, but since many cultures do not make that mistake it would be wrong for anthropologists themselves to take the binary perspective so it may have been perfectly reasonable to reject the workshop.

It also may be true that the explanation of the rejection given in an interview with the Chronicle of Higher Education was not optimal, and that the academic world as a whole has done a poor job of explaining complex (and sometimes counter-intuitive) things in simple terms. But a more credible article would have made some effort to identify how the explanation might have been improved.

(#) The fact that the joint distribution of several human characteristics is strongly bimodal may justify the claim that there are just two clearly identified “sexes”, but the existence of individuals who (for a whole variety of different reasons) do not clearly fall into either of those makes it immediately obvious (except in societies where the acknowledgement of such individuals is actively suppressed) that there is not a binary classification of all humans as one or the other.

Source: Opinion | Higher education is losing the public’s trust – The Washington Post

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Explaining(?) Gravity

A Quoran asks: What is gravity? Does it work like Sir Newton said or Like Sir Einstein said? Which definition is more accurate?

Gravity is the name we give to the fact that all (uncharged) matter tends to clump together.

For normal objects (including apples, moons, planets and stars) moving at normal speeds it works (so far as we can detect with normal instruments) exactly like Sir Newton said; but for objects moving more than a hundred thousand times the speed of sound (like subatomic particles in a high energy accelerator) or for very precise measurements over long periods of time (like observing the orbit of Mercury over many decades or coordinating the timing of super-accurate atomic clocks on GPS satellites) we can detect subtle differences. Most of these differences are consistent with what ‘Sir’ Einstein said, so that version is more accurate.

But whether or not it really works exactly like that is not certain, and in fact some observations (such as the rotation speeds of some galaxies) may not exactly fit (but we don’t yet know whether that means we need a new theory or just that there is more massive stuff in those galaxies than we thought there was). And also, since it’s not a “quantum” theory it may have to be modified in order to correctly describe how it works with elementary particles.

Isaac Newton first suggested that the way matter clumps together can be described by assigning a number (called “mass”) to each object and then, for each object, adding up acceleration vectors pointing towards all of the other objects whose magnitudes are proportional to the masses of the target objects and inversely proportional to the squares of the distances. This rule works perfectly well for the initial acceleration of objects that are stationary relative to one another – and before the invention of super-accurate atomic clocks, no deviation from it was ever detectable for macroscopic objects moving for short times at any achievable speed.

Albert Einstein noted that if the relationship between electricity and magnetism were to have the same form (and so to give the same apparent speed of light) for all observers, then space and time would have to be related in such a way that events which appear simultaneous to one observer might seem to be at different times for another observer who is moving relative to the first. (This relationship can be interpreted as a kind of “geometry” for the combined four dimensional space-time combination.)

In attempting to come up with a modification of Newton’s theory that fit with this, Einstein was led to a version which can be expressed in terms of how mass affects the relationship between space and time (in a way that can be interpreted as adding curvature to the “geometry”). And, as mentioned above, no observation has yet ruled out the possibility that this theory might really be exact.

Source: (1002) Alan Cooper’s answer to What is gravity? Does it work like Sir Newton said or Like Sir Einstein said? Which definition is more accurate? – Quora

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Post Secondary Experience

If, despite lowering standards only half the population gets to experience post-secondary indoctrination, then indeed this might drive an unhealthy bifurcation of political orientation. Perhaps we need a more universally shared experience for young adults – such as required period of quasi-military public service (including perhaps the proposed environmental disaster response force), during which more interaction between the various echo chambers might be encouraged.

Source: (1) We asked too much of the American university

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Insider Trading Loophole?

Do rules against insider trading really not prohibit the sale of insider information to third parties in advance of its public release?!!!

Source: Trump Media to Sell Real-Time Truth Social Feed to Traders – WSJ

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Who is Roger Pielke Jr.?

Roger Pielke Jr. has a long history of what some see as casting doubt on the need for prompt reduction of our CO2 emissions but which he categorizes just as exposing false and/or misleading claims (and sometimes even scientific malpractice) by advocates of climate action. This has led to great animosity and lawsuits between Pielke and some climate activists (esp Michael Mann ) and he claims to have been hounded out of various academic roles as a result.

He does not deny either the reality of anthropogenic global warming or the need for prompt action to reduce our emissions, but many of his followers do and he seems to make little effort to discourage them. And some of his complaints strike me as exaggerated to the point of verging on dishonesty.

This raises a conundrum in my mind regarding my ongoing concern with how we should react to wrong arguments for things that are true.

It is important to reject false arguments for things that are true, but if the true facts are important then it is also necessary to always accompany the exposure of a false argument with a correct and convincing argument for the same conclusion.

(NB An earlier version of this post was published in July of 2024)

Source: Why Climate Misinformation Persists – by Roger Pielke Jr.

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment

Experts Re-Convincing Themselves

The certainty with which “expert” opinions are expressed to the public on matters of public policy import is almost always greater than that with which the “experts”, if speaking honestly, would admit to one another. And on the other hand, those “experts” (and others) who distrust the “consensus” frequently exaggerate the extent and sources of doubt. But in this case I agree with Pielke that even if one has just a 10% credence in the lab leak origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus (as apparently was the case for at least some of the authors of the “Proximal Origin” paper), then that should by no means be considered as “case closed” and should motivate a much more serious investigation into whether or not a breach actually occurred, and into the effectiveness (and faithful application) of containment protocols in the research community as a whole.

Source: “We Just Need to Re-Convince Ourselves It’s Coincidence”

Posted in uncategorized | Leave a comment